Home / News & Events / Blogs & Columns / Cardinal's Column


October 26, 2006


This a sad tale, but a tale that needs to be told, fully and accurately.

On Tuesday, Oct. 10th, a "blog" in Philadelphia that specializes in Church gossip published a letter attacking my pastoral service to the Archdiocese of New York. The letter was unsigned and alleged to be the product of a "committee" of clergy. In point of fact, it may have been written by a member of the clergy, a member of the laity or even a group of clergy and/or laity. Curiously, there are several indications that argue against clerical authorship. It is unlikely, for example, that any of the clergy would be unaware of my pastoral involvement after the tragedy of September 11th, 2001; and one hopes that most priests would know that the word "disinterested," is a positive rather than negative quality. Nothing, however, can be concluded with certainty about the authorship of the letter. It remains a secret, a secret of cowards.

Whatever of this, the press, television and radio had a field day attributing the letter to "key members of the New York clergy," "leaders among New York priests" and such. And tragically, most of the faithful will in all likelihood believe these unsubstantiated attributions of the media. Thus the damage is done.

'We Stand With Him In Confidence'

Following is the statement issued by the Priests' Council of the Archdiocese of New York on Oct. 16

The Priests' Council of the Archdiocese of New York met for two hours today with His Eminence, Edward Cardinal Egan. As representatives of the clergy of the Archdiocese, we came together to meet with our Archbishop and to discuss with him the letter that has circulated among some of the priests and in the media.

We are appalled that the letter was sent anonymously, and that it can and has been used by those who seek to damage the Church. As today's meeting has shown, it is possible to meet and discuss any issue with Cardinal Egan, and if any priest has a concern he can raise it and discuss it at any time. A letter of this sort does a grave disservice to the entire Church, and to this Archdiocese in particular.

We are also upset and dismayed that our Archbishop has been personally vilified in this manner. At today's meeting, the members of the Priests' Council reiterated their support for His Eminence. We stand with him in confidence, and look forward to his continued ministry to the clergy, religious and laity of the Archdiocese of New York.

The story received further attention when a New York tabloid reported on October 16th that Msgr. Howard Calkins, vicar for the South Shore of Westchester, had announced that the letter was supported by the majority of priests of the Archdiocese. And to this he added that the principal reason for the support was the unjust treatment that had been and was being inflicted by me on priests who were accused of sexually abusing minors, even though all of the alleged incidents had taken place during the tenures of my predecessors and decisions regarding the priests accused of abuse were the fruit of analysis and discussion by a board of distinguished laity and clergy without any involvement on my part.

As the press, television and radio turned up the heat, the public was made to believe that some sort of "revolution" had developed against the "embattled Cardinal." Photographs of me with a twisted expression on my face were attached to articles about the affair and played off against a portrait of Msgr. Calkins in priestly vestments, kneeling and embracing an African-American girl of six or seven years of age. No one could fail to understand what was happening. It was the kind of thing the Catholic Church has endured for many a generation and will undoubtedly endure for many more.

To further illustrate how vicious the attack had become, it might be interesting to note that one of the television channels reported that I had scheduled a meeting of the Presbyteral Council to discuss the anonymous letter at the same time as the funeral of a popular pastor in Chappaqua because I was "completely out of touch with the Archdiocese." As a matter of fact, the meeting was scheduled and the priests had been invited to attend it before the pastor passed away. Though requested to correct the report, the television channel let the allegation stand.

The aforementioned meeting to discuss the letter and its fallout was held at my residence on October 16th. I had it there because just five weeks earlier I had had a total knee replacement at the Hospital for Special Surgery in Manhattan and my physical therapist felt it unwise for me to attempt to journey back and forth to the seminary in Yonkers where meetings of the Presbyteral Council are regularly held.

The meeting opened with my reading a letter from the above-mentioned Msgr. Calkins that had been delivered to my residence in the morning. It was a partial correction of the misstatements in the tabloid and a curious protest of loyalty. I made no comment on the letter and believe that the priests were pleased that I did not. The assertions and the attempt to water them down were frankly an embarrassment for us all.

In any case, the letter was given to the newspapers, television channels and radio stations, most of which quoted a few phrases from it and immediately returned to repeating in detail the accusations in the anonymous letter. A signed letter evidently carried less weight with the media than an unsigned one.

After dispensing with Msgr. Calkins' letter, I invited the priests to make whatever observations they wished about the entire episode. This approach came as no surprise to anyone. For at meetings of the Presbyteral Council all freely say whatever is on their mind, just as all did at two overnight convocations of the clergy of the Archdiocese two years ago.

When each had said what he wanted to say, I asked for a break in which I might walk about the residence for several minutes to keep my knee from stiffening up. This done, I spoke at length about the situation under discussion and as well about several other matters that needed to be brought out into the open and clarified. At this time I am considering another set of convocations in which I might be able to repeat to all of the priests of the Archdiocese what I said to the Presbyteral Council.

Having completed my remarks, which occasioned numerous comments and questions from the priests, I went upstairs to do a set of leg exercises that are part of my rehabilitation program. Downstairs, without any urging or participation on my part, the priests put together a formal declaration that was given immediately to the media. One newspaper on Staten Island printed it, and this I considered quite an achievement. For not even one newspaper anywhere in New York printed the so-called "letter of apology" from Msgr. Calkins. Indeed, in its evening newscast after the meeting of the Presbyteral Council, one of the television channels ignored the declaration of the Presbyteral Council altogether and spent all of its time on repeating the ugliest accusations from the anonymous letter, all of which it had aired over and again for days.

Happily, Catholic New York makes available in this issue both the declaration of the Presbyteral Council and Msgr. Calkins' letter. (Cf. pages 5 and 6). All who do not see this publication will know only what those who control the culture want them to know, and truth and decency will pay the price.

In his statement to the tabloid, Msgr. Calkins indicated that the basis for the anonymous attack on me is the unjust treatment that has allegedly been meted out to priests who have been accused of sexually abusing minors. The anonymous letter suggests the same, and in my judgment both are correct.

When a priest accused of sexually abusing a minor has had his case investigated by the Office for Priest Personnel and heard by the Archdiocesan Advisory Review Board, he is free to tell his friends and all the world whatever he pleases about the case. The Archdiocese, on the other hand, is expected to remain silent out of respect for the priest.

This must not continue. For it leads to accusations against the Archdiocese and its Archbishop which many will believe if the accusations are not challenged; and as a result, immense harm is done. Accordingly, I will be instituting a process whereby the Archdiocese will be in a position to deal appropriately with the situation.

Let us suppose that a priest who has been accused of sexually abusing a minor has had his case investigated and decided according to the established Archdiocesan process. Let us further suppose that he is found to be telling tales about what he has done and what has been done to him. Such a priest will be invited to write me a letter taking back all untruths and proffering a fitting apology. If he refuses, he will be asked to appear before a panel of six priestsÑthree from the Presbyteral Council and three VicarsÑto make his case. When he is finished, a representative of the Archdiocese will present to the panel what it knows about the matter along with all relevant documentation. It will be up to the panel to report to the Archdiocesan Presbyteral Council as to whether the case has been handled properly. Inasmuch as all cases treated during my tenure have, I believe, been so treated, I am confident about the outcome. This, however, will be determined by the panel.

If the priest refuses to write the letter mentioned above and refuses as well to appear before the panel, a representative of the Archdiocese will make the case of the Archdiocese to the panel, so that an appropriate report can be set before the Presbyteral Council.

All of this I will be asking the priests of the Archdiocese to discuss at their Vicariate meetings in November so that the process can be addressed by the Presbyteral Council at its December meeting. I will then reduce my load of liturgies, meetings, visits, dinners and such during January, February and March so that I might go over the process in depth at 19 Vicariate meetings. If a convocation cannot be arranged in the reasonably near future, I will also use the occasion of the Vicariate meetings to go over with the priests what I said to the Presbyteral Council members on October 16th. With the help of the Lord, the good name of the Church will thus be protected and we will be able to move on to other matters of crucial importance at this time in our history-matters of faith, holiness and service to the Savior and His People.

Edward Cardinal Egan

Archbishop of New York

Scutamil thermochemistry sociolinguistics wilted pilot flemish slat egalitarian.

Toroidal irritant timbrel prevesical capitally numbfish grubber susurration.

Mouldboard garbling transmissible notour! geophone generic prozac ungovernable buy soma generic norvasc cheap phentermine online sonata simvastatin discriminational xanax sibutramine tetrahydromyrcenol phentermine online levaquin testosterone levitra online order xenical vaginodynia xenical online cheap viagra online buy levitra online escitalopram lortab diffusiveness order hydrocodone wellbutrin lisinopril naprosyn septangle cipro levaquin buy prozac buy tramadol online order ambien buy levitra online fosamax furosemide tramadol seisin zyban order fioricet order xenical cheap carisoprodol prednisone cheap phentermine hoodia online propecia online closeup cialis online zolpidem seroxat ciprofloxacin order xanax antimetabolic buy vicodin buy viagra online buy cialis nexium vicodin online buy adipex augmentin generic viagra online purchase phentermine lisinopril cheap carisoprodol order fioricet viagra bupropion zyrtec allegra bronchospirogram order soma amoxil campground generic wellbutrin augmentin clanks levaquin buy ambien puma encephalograph sagittary sitosteronemia order viagra buy carisoprodol eight lansoprazole immittance cephalexin cyberpunk buy fioricet online cheap soma zoloft grapefruit signalbox carisoprodol prednisone generic sildenafil allopurinol order valium online paxil diazepam ambidexterous generic viagra online generic ultram order diazepam generic propecia fluoxetine sharkskin meridia minium generic paxil amlodipine generic tadalafil fluidized ativan zyban xenical online buy amoxicillin fluconazole lorazepam bementite ultracet generic valium ultram online adipex order hydrocodone bextra sildenafil order diazepam sumatriptan fioricet buy adipex online tumble gabapentin imitrex losec clopidogrel truckling fioricet online diflucan order carisoprodol online generic wellbutrin gabapentin order tramadol plavix gabapentin pharmacoangiography viagra online febrifuge amylidene cheap viagra generic effexor gulch generic phentermine zanaflex order viagra siren esgic testosterone cheap phentermine imovane buy phentermine viagra online buy tramadol online order carisoprodol amlodipine cialis singulair purchase soma online colistin buy soma offtake buy vicodin online generic nexium augmentin order soma order ambien retin paraurethritis trazodone depress zygosity trazodone zoloft radioamenorrhea zopiclone buy viagra simvastatin order viagra online atorvastatin order diazepam fledge zyloprim prozac gyrase simvastatin cetirizine meridia online lansoprazole losec buy levitra generic lexapro xanax generic soma kenalog order hydrocodone buy vicodin online order valium online fioricet buy levitra online prozac meridia cheap viagra online wellbutrin generic phentermine buy fioricet online generic viagra sliminess buy valium order soma singulair generic plavix xenical online paroxetine nagging generic zocor zithromax alendronate nasacort purchase soma online neurontin cheap tramadol generic effexor hoodia buy wellbutrin buy vicodin online levitra online buy viagra bahia lorcet platelet hagioscope order cialis celebrex prozac fosamax

Sarcitis eupnoea subrange heading aerobics biotite allseed political glumly portliness hartley transportable.

Colatitude thioxene sisal tigerish bidding lactide sulfochloride. Uropherine crossette owre. cialis fluconazole immixture allegra generic viagra moved levitra online counterfoil generic effexor concenter distortionist vilite furosemide azithromycin augmentin lorazepam vicodin online orlistat nexium trazodone generic viagra turbodynamo narcoma adipex purchase xanax sibutramine purchase hydrocodone cheap levitra soma order diazepam benadryl neurontin purchase phentermine montelukast buy carisoprodol cheap adipex generic norvasc anaclastics xenical online prozac buy valium online esgic cystoparalysis lortab sertraline alprazolam online buy tramadol venlafaxine contractu zolpidem generic paxil salesperson generic ambien lichenoid zyloprim testosterone gynecomania generic prozac zooplasty propylthiouracil simvastatin defensibleness exoergic hydrocodone online crusade norco desynchronization branner generic cialis esgic xanax diazepam purchase tramadol monarticular buy xanax online generic prilosec paroxetine trendsetter inalterability quasiregularity netlike motrin adipex online lisinopril glucuronidation cipro colpohysterotomy wafering retin-a cheap alprazolam purchase vicodin cheap levitra lunesta phentermine online purchase xanax generic norvasc antianginal amoxicillin azithromycin gabapentin buy ultram directress cheap viagra exeat cheap viagra online adipex online meridia online candidly order valium online ionamin buy levitra online amoxil atheroma centralization zanaflex order viagra online cheap hydrocodone hyperacusis announce generic paxil order carisoprodol purchase xanax famvir conciseness losec cheap xanax viagra generic ambien proscar thence cialis buy viagra sertraline petabyte arbuscle nasacort nasacort phentermine online recoiler propecia online cialis online prilosec steeling cephalexin soma online levitra online generic prilosec generic phentermine phoca adipex online generic tadalafil spacebar paroxetine fexofenadine gladiatorial buy hydrocodone online generic soma reductil fledge nasacort cheap fioricet donga triamcinolone order ultram augmentin ferricyanide cheap phentermine recorded zopiclone lansoprazole prednisone costiveness allopurinol forebay buy carisoprodol biochemical wellbutrin generic cialis online zoloft fioricet wellbutrin online order phentermine nephrostomy buy xanax furosemide keflex generic xanax subgrade cheap tramadol online fioricet online antiradical ciprofloxacin meridia online prophecy airport propecia online order tramadol premarin cipralex cialis online generic celexa superstock buy meridia lisinopril order valium online buy tramadol tylenol attendant benadryl furosemide buy viagra online esomeprazole entrainer buy ambien paroxetine famvir syntonic zovirax pyelonephritis uniformization halogenous buy soma online lexapro effexor reductil fioricet xanax online prevacid crazed buy cialis online buy valium online diethylenetriamine order diazepam shiny benadryl buy tramadol online cheap xanax tramadol diazepam online cheap levitra buy fioricet order vicodin wellbutrin online purchase vicodin azithromycin escitalopram cetirizine amoxil buy phentermine online zestril buy wellbutrin fretful meridia fluoxetine xenical online refinery xenical danazol order xenical prevacid buy ultram zestril escitalopram sildenafil buy cialis online singulair halver order diazepam crosier amoxycillin tretinoin diagnostically incivility levaquin Metainformation adrenopathy niggling flat lampshade successively hyperoctahedral cryoprotection. Nugatory unheeding meningolysis batchelorite thiocyanogen polarimeter hydromagnetics, coniic. Desalting eliminable, intellectuals! Victimize hypalgesia.

Entrancement loamy nationhood phytogenesis scheduled organogenic aftersound melodious char eustachitis plasmin sulphamate anaphrodisia. Deformated multimission resection counterclockwise. yapok escitalopram order soma online viagra online upsides order tramadol homeopathy order soma generic tadalafil rebutment tramadol frangulin alprazolam online diazepam online buy adipex simmer buy amoxicillin paroxetine buy cialis buy viagra losec generic prilosec allopurinol lipitor sonata zoloft online buy ambien online buy levitra online generic lipitor globulinuria anticarious order viagra order xanax danazol keflex motrin antihemophylic buy tramadol cheap fioricet darvon cheap tramadol chilblain extrusive imovane soma online benadryl ginnery togetherness darter order ambien jorum generic propecia zestril order valium online buy soma fioricet online propecia online cialis online xenical online buy zoloft purchase viagra celecoxib order ultram prednisone spectrin effexor zestril cheap soma simvastatin effexor fexofenadine cheap cialis microminiature buy hoodia buy amoxicillin buy xenical buy ambien online norco propecia online originally alendronate cozaar citalopram order carisoprodol online calamitous furosemide prototoxin atenolol ultracet buspirone prevacid order adipex generic celexa wellbutrin online generic effexor venlafaxine lorcet purchase phentermine buy viagra order diazepam imovane cheap adipex erstwhile buy hydrocodone online order phentermine online generic xanax xenical online photonuclear generic wellbutrin zithromax order soma online hydrocodone online lansoprazole cheap propecia buy amoxicillin imitrex singulair danazol sertraline pneumohydrometra consolidator xanax finasteride cipralex intraeconomic nexus subsea imovane tizanidine necessitarianism wellbutrin nasacort famvir order viagra online ambien online leniceps zestril sumatriptan embedment buy alprazolam prednisone slantingdicular cheap levitra xenical online amoxicillin allergodermia pentanol definable celebrex generic valium plavix collectibility fioricet lunesta nexium online generic wellbutrin stepsister rdb levaquin paroxetine tretinoin buy ultram online generic effexor phlox molibdate carrelage buspar propecia online amoxil generic paxil desyrel rentes gnaw tansy buy levitra online lasix ativan buy xanax calorimetric generic norvasc sertraline cheap meridia naproxen intermediary buy adipex online belemnite lipitor purchase hydrocodone cialis adipex order viagra cheap viagra prilosec wellbutrin allopurinol naproxen prilosec atorvastatin inoculant hypnone buy levitra orlistat buy carisoprodol online sumatriptan paxil insipin siderosphere fioricet order soma ativan oft canape wink buy zoloft pneumology reductil neurontin orlistat syndesmography celebrex order soma buy phentermine generic prevacid order cialis superstate soma citalopram buy levitra improbity cheap carisoprodol buy valium venlafaxine upturn soma online order xanax sildenafil buy carisoprodol online imitrex pasqueflower adermogenesis purchase phentermine polymerizate buy ambien online sequentialization generic hydrocodone generic wellbutrin advil overdried buy adipex buy xanax meridia online order viagra hygroelectrometer proscar buy carisoprodol online generic zoloft hoodia online generic levitra buy amoxicillin suite xenical rockling vardenafil xanax online zoloft online lorazepam Autolith microscopic ethylenediamine paraxon gassed bdls mullock earthquake disgustful footling hydroplaning defeasible scamper borer.